Advertisement
Recipes

20 best bake sale recipes

Remember that time you almost forgot about the school bake sale? These recipes have your back. Some are super-simple, others are for the love of baking. Choose your own adventure.

20 best bake sale recipes

Photo: Erik Putz

Best bake sale recipes

Chocolate Chip Cookie Bar

Introducing the bake-sale saviour. Chewy, chocolatey cookies are so much easier when they can be patted down into one big pan and cut into bars. Get the recipe: Chocolate Chip Cookie Bar

 

Chocolate chip cookie bars arranged on a green backgroundPhoto: Erik Putz

Blueberry-Ginger Muffins

Kyle’s mom is already bringing banana muffins, so try these blueberry-ginger babies instead. Ginger is an antioxidant, so you’re basically stopping gross school germs in their tracks here. Get the recipe: Blueberry-Ginger Muffins

blueberry muffin recipePhoto: Roberto Caruso

Advertisement

Maple Fudge

You’re just three ingredients away from this melt-in-your-mouth fudge. Hi, butter, whipping cream and maple syrup. Get the recipe: Maple Fudge

fudge shaped like squirrelsPhoto: Erik Putz

Salted Brown Butter Puffed Rice Treats

Turns out you’ve been making these wrong your whole life. Here’s how to make it rightt: Let the melted butter get nutty and brown, then add salt. These are better than all the rest. Get the recipe: Salted Brown Butter Puffed Rice Treats

cutting board with marshmallow-y puffed rice squaresPhoto: Erik Putz

Chocolate Pretzel Granola Bars

Look at you making your own granola bars. They really don’t require a lot of effort, and with sweet chocolate and salty pretzels up to bat, they’ll be a home run at that bake sale. Get the recipe: Chocolate Pretzel Granola Bars

tray of homemade granola bars with chocolate chipsPhoto: Roberto Caruso

Advertisement

White Chocolate Crunch

If you’re looking to outshine the other parents at the bake sale, may we suggest these addictive little bites? It’s the perfect combination of sweet and salty, with a silky white chocolate body that’s riddled with pretzels, potato chips, toffee and a hint of lemon zest for good measure. Get the recipe: White Chocolate Crunch

paper-covered box with fudgey squares insidePhoto: Ryan Szulc

Tahini Cookies

Tahini is a paste made from sesame seeds and is school-safe. You probably met over a grain bowl, but give tahini a try in your baking. It makes a soft and mild cookie that’s just a little bit salty (and not because its mad at anyone). Get the recipe: Tahini Cookies

tahini cookies with sesame seedsPhoto: Erik Putz

Hot Chocolate Whoopie Pies

Hands up if you like baking. Well, lucky you, these squishy, cream-filled cookies are delicious—but you’ve got to work for them. We’re definitely throwing our money down for these guys. Get the recipe: Hot Chocolate Whoopie Pies

plate of homemade whoopee piesPhoto: Roberto Caruso

Advertisement

Rocky Road Brownies

Sinking your teeth into a fudgy brownie is the best. Imagine that sweet treat topped with toasted mallows. Yeah, we did that. Get the recipe: Rocky Road Brownies 

plate of marshmallow-topped browniesPhoto: Roberto Caruso

Cinnamon Toast Kettle Corn

Salty-sweet kettle corn is something you just can’t stop munching. Pack it up in individual baggies and watch it all disappear. Get the recipe: Cinnamon Toast Kettle Corn

plastic lunch container with cinnamon popcornPhoto: Roberto Caruso

S’mores Faux Ice Cream Sandwiches

OK, but who says you actually have to “bake” for a bake sale? Here’s your cheater method: Store-bought bakery cookies sandwiching marshmallow fluff that’s been mixed with graham cracker crumbs and chocolate chips. You’re welcome. Get the recipe: S’mores Faux Ice Cream Sandwiches

Stack of chocolate cookies with marshmallow fluff in the middlePhoto: Vincent Noguchi

Advertisement

Cranberry and White Chocolate Squares

Squares rule because they’re easy to make, a breeze to dole out and are always delicious. In this case, it's a blondie base that’s got cranberries and white chocolate chunks sprinkled throughout. If you’re feeling wild, get in there with some dark chocolate, too. Get the recipe: Cranberry and White Chocolate Squares

Stack of squares with chopped dried cranberries, chocolate and white chocolate drizzlePhoto: Ryan Szulc

Big Batch Oatmeal Chocolate Raisin Cookies

This recipe yields 75 cookies, meaning you can make enough for this week’s bake sale then stash the rest of the dough, portioned into logs in the freezer, for when the next bake sale creeps up—or for those late-night cookie cravings. We like to call it Cookies on Demand. Get the recipe: Big Batch Oatmeal Chocolate Raisin Cookies

Cooling tray with oatmeal chocolate chip and raisin cookiesPhoto: Erik Putz

Double Lemon Bars

Check out this silky citrus layer that’s hanging out on a buttery base, dusted with icing sugar and decorated with candied lemon for extra pizazz. How do you like those lemons? Yeah, we thought you’d like that. Get the recipe: Double Lemon Bars

squares of lemon bars on parchment paper with candied lemon on topPhoto: Ryan Szulc

Advertisement

Raspberry Sweetheart Cookies

If you’re a minimal-effort baker (this is a safe space, it’s OK), these heart-shaped cookies are for you. Puff pastry, jam and sugar. That’s it. Get the recipe: Raspberry Sweetheart Cookies

box of heart-shaped cookiesRoberto Caruso

The Ultimate Chocolate Chocolate Chunk Cookie

There’s a lot going on in these chocolate morsels—a lot of good stuff. Allow us to elaborate: A fudgy brownie-like cookie base + dried cherries + white chocolate chunks + chocolate chunks. Go forth and make these, please. Get the recipe: The Ultimate Chocolate Chocolate Chunk Cookie

stack of chocolate cookiesPhoto: John Cullen

Cheddar and Bacon Scones

With all those sweets, it’s nice to break it up with a little savoury. A flakey, cheesy and bacon-y biscuit is the perfect solution. Get the recipe: Cheddar and Bacon Scones

plate of freshly baked scones

Advertisement

Blueberry Hand Pies

If you’re looking to stand out against a sea of cookies and muffins, these hand pies are looking at you. Get the recipe: Blueberry Hand Pies

folded pastry with blueberry filling

Cheesy Gold Star Crackers

Gold star goes to you for making your own crackers. Who even are you and can we be your friend? Get the recipe: Cheesy Gold Star Crackers

crackers in the shape of starsPhoto: Roberto Caruso

Old-Fashioned Cake Donut Rings and Holes

Looking for a weekend project? Say hello to these fried donuts. Alternatively, you could drive to your local bakery and shop for fried dough there. Get the recipe: Old-Fashioned Cake Donut Rings and Holes

Pink platter with sugar-coated doughnut rings and doughnut holesPhoto: Andrew Grinton

Read more: 10 easy recipes for kids 15 recipe projects to take on this weekend 9 ballin' ball recipes

This article was originally published on Aug 22, 2019

Weekly Newsletter

Keep up with your baby's development, get the latest parenting content and receive special offers from our partners

I understand that I may withdraw my consent at any time.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Advertisement
Advertisement