Family health

Cold or allergy?

Sniffing out the difference

By Cathie Kryczka
Cold or allergy?

Sniff, sniff, sniff — it’s a familiar, though never welcome, sound. It’s the time of year when you wonder if your child’s runny nose is signalling yet another cold or a springtime allergy.

The sniff diff

Colds and allergies often look the same for the first couple of days, says Liliane Gendreau-Reid, a Victoria paediatrician and allergist: Both start with sneezing and a runny nose. Then you may notice differences:

• A child with an allergy usually has itchy eyes, palate (upper part of mouth) or throat.

• An allergy produces a watery nasal discharge (with a cold, the mucus discharge may be yellow or green, and often it’s thicker).

• A child with an allergy won’t usually be sick. “You don’t get any fever when you have a runny nose from an allergy,” says Gary Smith, a community paediatrician and member of the Canadian Paediatric Society’s subcommittee on public education. “And when you get a cold, you feel ill all over; you have aches and pains and generally quite a sore throat.”

The age factor

Kids catch colds at all ages. Most kids develop a runny nose from allergies starting at six to eight years, says Gendreau-Reid (although it can happen at other ages).

 Family history

If you have allergies, your child may too. One allergic parent gives a child up to a 25 percent risk of having allergies; with two parents it rises to more than 50 percent.

Timing and duration

A cold will stick around for a week to 10 days, then clear up. With an allergy, however, it depends on the trigger. If it’s a pet at a friend’s house, the runny nose will last a day or so; if it’s pollen, the timing will be specific (only in the spring) and the symptoms will be worse outdoors. (If your child’s cold lasts more than seven to 10 days, it could be a sinus infection — that’s like a cold that drags on with a sore throat or pain in the sinuses. Check with her doctor.)

What to do

• Figure out what’s causing the runny nose — if you can — and avoid it. (For help, check the Weather Network’s pollen forecast:

• There’s no cure for allergies. The best you can do is treat the symptoms. Lots of kids are given cough and cold remedies for a runny nose, and that’s OK if the child is over six, says Smith. Many of these products contain antihistamines and decongestants, which give some symptom relief.

• Gendreau-Reid suggests trying an antihistamine (for children over two) because during the first couple of days, it will work for either a cold or allergy. If this doesn’t seem to help or if you need antihistamines more than three times a week, talk to your child’s doctor. Also check in if the runny nose is making your child uncomfortable — your physician may recommend another medication.

This article was originally published on Mar 08, 2010

Weekly Newsletter

Keep up with your baby's development, get the latest parenting content and receive special offers from our partners

I understand that I may withdraw my consent at any time.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.