From the age of four, Nancy Vonk’s daughter was unhappy with her hair. “She wanted long, straight blond hair, and she had curly brown hair,” says the Toronto mother. As the girl grew older, she started worrying about her appearance. One day, Vonk asked, “Lily, why do you let yourself be sucked into this? You know this isn’t realistic.” Her tween daughter replied, “It doesn’t matter what I know. It’s what the world is holding up.”
Seeing her daughter struggle with unrealistic beauty expectations gave Vonk, co-chief creative officer at the ad agency Ogilvy & Mather Canada, even greater pride in a now well-known ad campaign her agency helped develop for Dove. Titled “Campaign for Real Beauty,” it includes a Self-Esteem Fund that lets girls learn and talk about beauty imagery. Vonk has since seen other advertisers adopt a similar message. “There’s some effort to show a consciousness of the issue,” she says, “but whether there’s really a meaningful shift underway, I don’t know.
Parents’ and health professionals’ growing alarm about how advertising affects children is causing some companies to review their ad practices. This is especially true among food and beverage manufacturers, which are facing growing calls for bans on advertising to children as child obesity rates soar. More than a third of respondents to our survey want to see ads aimed at kids banned outright, and 40% of the rest would like restrictions placed on the products promoted and the age of kids targeted. Yet it’s far from certain that banning ads would have much effect. Technology changes rapidly, there are loopholes in every rule and many of today’s most effective ways of getting kids hooked on brands fly under the radar of parents and regulators.
Television, which 96% of our survey respondents let their kids watch, is the most ubiquitous advertising source — but also the most strictly regulated. In Canada, commercials aimed at kids under 12 can’t use words like “new” or “introducing” for products that have been on the market more than a year; they can’t urge kids to buy (or ask their parents to buy) products; and they can’t suggest that using the product will make the child better than other kids. Companies also can’t use well-known kids’ entertainers or cartoon characters in their promotions, nor can their mascots appear in kids’ shows, to avoid blurring the line between ads and the programming. And advertisers are prevented from showing more than one commercial for the same product within a half-hour period.
What’s being done for kids
But more and more people fear that isn’t enough. A year ago, MP Peter Julian introduced a bill seeking to extend a ban on children’s advertising — which has been in place in Quebec since 1980 — across the country. And this past February, Toronto’s medical officer of health cited obesity concerns in recommending a ban on food advertising to kids under 13. Most recently, the Chronic Disease Prevention Alliance of Canada brought together key players, including health experts and advertisers, to examine the relationship between obesity and marketing to children. That conference resulted in a call to end “all marketing of unhealthy food and beverages to children within two years.”
Even before that call was issued in March, food and beverage companies were worried enough about regulations — and the prospect of lawsuits related to obesity — to have recently announced a voluntary commitment to less advertising of nutritionally questionable food to kids. The 16 companies, ranging from Weston Bakeries to McDonald’s Restaurants of Canada, promise to direct their budgets for kids’ marketing to more nutritious choices. Diana Carradine of Concerned Children’s Advertisers, an advocacy group comprising many of Canada’s biggest brands, points out the marketers behind this initiative represent 90% of ad spending in Canada, and eight of the 16 will stop advertising to preteens altogether. The foods they continue to promote “will reflect the principal advice of the Canada Food Guide,” she says, though (loophole alert!) the companies have leeway to interpret those guidelines and define which products comply.
Banning commercials, of course, leaves many other advertising forms out there. Studies have shown that kids nag as often for products, and parents give in as often, whether they see TV advertising or not. While some studies indicate the Quebec ban has trimmed families’ fast-food spending in that province, there are conflicting claims on whether the rates of obesity have budged. And, of course, advancing technology makes any bans difficult to enforce. “I frankly wasn’t aware of the ban until you brought it up,” says Lyle Stewart, a Montreal father of four ranging from a baby to a 13-year-old. He subscribes to satellite television, so his family has a choice of many national and US channels. “Therein lies the limitation of such a ban,” he says. “With satellite and Internet TV, your options are far wider and cannot be limited by government intervention.”
Somehow, ads always manage to sneak through cracks in regulations. Kids often watch so-called family shows with their parents, where many advertising restrictions don’t apply. In Quebec, companies can get around the ban by saying that their target market is kids over 13.
Vonk, for one, is encouraged by the shifting tone in some advertising to kids, both as a mother and as an ad executive. While some of the efforts promoting nutrition, self-esteem and environmental protection strike her as blatantly insincere, she’s glad to see the ad community weighing its messages more closely. “We get caught up in what we can do, without thinking enough, ‘Is this the right thing to do?’ It’d be great if it was a fundamental shift. But I think we’d be naive to think that, OK, job done.”
What parents believe is accomplished through advertising
93% Encourage children to request products
62% Create brand awareness and loyalty
50% Promote unhealthy products or habits
35% Influence child’s sense of identity or self-esteem
31% Provide information about products of interest to kids
11% Promote healthy products or habits
Introducing the My Family App
Enter your due date or your kid’s birth date to get a customized newsfeed of tips, recipes, developmental advice and health information, plus handy tools like the Nap Tracker and Potty Pal. You’ll love our Storybook feature, which turns your favourite moments into digital scrapbooks.